Also this weekend was the Harry Potter vs Twilight debate at the library, which was a lot of fun. The auditorium was packed (so at least 250 people), and the audience enthusiastic. A panel of five judges from the library & the school system asked questions of the two teams, each made up of three teen girls from Team Read. On one hand, I’m sorry that there weren’t any boys on the panels, though there were many among the teen volunteers, but on the other, how awesome is it that girls were debating what’s the best fantasy series? Totally awesome, that’s what.

The judges would ask a question, and then the teams were given 30 seconds to discuss it amongst themselves before responding. After each question, the audience would spring into lively discussion too, which was very cool.
The teams were asked to discuss supporting characters (Twilight talked about Jacob, HP about Neville OF COURSE BECAUSE NEVILLE IS THE BEST. Ahem.), villains, prejudice (a missed opportunity to discuss werewolves & Native Americans in Twilight, imho), and the responsibility of having supernatural powers (where team HP made the excellent observation that Twilight is about suppressing desire and not abuse of power).
Finally came the question you KNEW team HP had been waiting for, to discuss how women were portrayed. After reeling off strong & compelling female characters in HP, both heroes and villains, they moved on to smack down Twilight. The quote I took down was that Bella is “a stereotypical weak, dependent girl, and that is not an image to be putting on teenage girls.” The entire auditorium erupted in cheering and applause. It was FABULOUS. Particularly as team Twilight, in their rebuttal, said “I have to admit, that was really good.” They argued that Bella is relatable because we all have friends we want to smack, and that girls can choose to not be like her. It was a creative perspective, to be sure.
The judges tacked on an extra question about why the books deserve such popularity, and the Twilight folks totally failed to offer any reasons to make me read past the first 2/3 of the first book. If you somehow managed to escape knowing everything I hate about it & yet amazingly remain curious, buy me a coffee sometime.
In the final statements, team HP offered the final coup de grĂ¢ce in a quote from Stephanie Meyer, praising Rowling’s work, and Harry Potter ruled the day, winning judges’ decision and the audience vote.
Good times!